Stature estimation of the Malaysian population based on sacrum CT scans

Soon, Lai Poh; Noor, Mohamad Helmee Mohamad; Abdullah, Nurliza; Hadi, Helmi

doi:10.1186/s41935-020-00192-5

Egyptian Journal of Forensic Sciences

Table 9 Comparison of regression analysis reported by the previous studies and the present study for stature estimation

From: Stature estimation of the Malaysian population based on sacrum CT scans

Authors	Modalities	Population	Sex	Sample size	Formula P2	SEE	R	Formula P6	SEE	R
Pelin et al. (2005)	MRI	Caucasian	Male	42				142.79 + 2.58 × P6	± 6.59	0.432
Giroux and Wescott (2008)	Dry bone	Black American	Male	57				143.773 + 3.117 × P6	± 6.96	0.460
	Dry bone	Black American	Female	38				133.675 + 2.898 × P6	± 7.21	0.440
		White American	Male	92				149.812 + 2.461 × P6	± 7.17	0.390
		White American	Female	60				154.003 + 0.883 × P6	± 7.73	0.130
Pininski and Brits (2014)	Dry bone	Black African	Male	50	155.320 + 2.976 × P2	± 6.95	0.260	139.892 + 3.193 × P6	± 6.69	0.370
	Dry bone	Black African	Female	58	157.591 + 0.727 × P2	± 6.93	0.050	126.979 + 3.694 × P6	± 5.90	0.530
			Overall	108	137.928 + 5.468 × P2	± 8.03	0.390	118.867 + 4.930 × P6	± 7.30	0.550
		White African	Male	51	152.770 + 3.496 × P2	± 8.52	0.250	148.650 + 2.298 × P6	± 8.53	0.250
		White African	Female	51	149.037 + 2.684 × P2	± 6.76	0.240	139.373 + 2.353 × P6	± 6.59	0.330
			Overall	102	140.112 + 5.093 × P2	± 8.55	0.370	136.261 + 3.084 × P6	± 8.71	0.320
Torimitsu et al. (2017)	CT	Japanese	Male	110				132.69 + 0.32 × P6	± 5.98	0.216
			Female	106				115.33 + 0.38 × P6	± 7.84	0.220
			Overall	216				104.45 + 0.53 × P6	± 8.29	0.345
Wagner et al. (2017)	CT	European	Overall	75						0.371
Zhan et al. (2018)	CT	Chinese	Male	190				136.477 + 2.662 × P6	± 5.83	0.416
Zhan et al. (2018)			Female	160				133.867 + 1.948 × P6	± 5.55	0.294
Present study (2019)	CT	Malaysian	Male	186	162.440 + 0.850 × P2	± 7.53	0.075	146.889 + 1.909 × P6	± 7.32	0.243
			Female	175	151.658 + 0.851 × P2	± 7.25	0.077	129.631 + 2.605 × P6	± 6.78	0.356
			Overall	361	151.123 + 2.131 × P2	± 9.10	0.156	129.907 + 3.091 × P6	± 8.69	0.332

Back to article page