Skip to main content

Table 2 Findings of Wilcoxon signed-rank test for scores of fingermarks retrieved from depletion and ageing studies upon each tested surface

From: Nanocarbon powder for latent fingermark development: a green chemistry approach

Material

Negative rank

Positive rank

Ties

Sig./p value

Z

N

Median CNP18

Median BP

Multiple donors studies

Porcelain crucible

6

11

19

0.435

− 0.776b

36

2.5

2.0

Depletion studies

Porcelain crucible

9

8

13

0.403

− 0.836b

30

2.0

2.5

Electrical switch

4

20

6

0.001

− 3.229c

30

4.0

1.5

Tempered glass

18

3

9

0.001

− 3.422b

30

2.0

3.0

Stainless steel tool

9

14

7

0.076

− 1.775c

30

2.0

2.0

Glossed wood

20

2

8

0.000

− 3.788b

30

0.0

1.5

CD-ROM

7

6

17

0.829

− 0.216c

30

3.0

3.0

Brown tape

17

3

10

0.002

− 3.144b

30

3.0

4.0

Credit card

14

5

11

0.340

− 0.955b

30

3.0

3.0

Currency note

24

1

5

0.000

− 4.274b

30

0.0

2.0

Translucent plastic

20

1

9

0.000

− 3.886b

30

2.5

4.0

Ageing studies

Porcelain crucible

8

4

9

0.266

− 1.112b

21

4.0

5.0

Electrical switch

15

2

4

0.003

− 2.960b

21

1.0

3.0

Tempered glass

6

1

14

0.031

− 2.156b

21

5.0

5.0

Stainless steel tool

1

6

14

0.058

− 1.897c

21

4.0

4.0

Glossed wood

12

3

6

0.002

− 3.041b

21

2.0

3.0

CD-ROM

5

8

8

0.740

− 0.332c

21

4.0

4.0

Brown tape

3

1

17

0.317

− 1.000b

21

1.0

1.0

Credit card

11

2

8

0.015

− 2.433b

21

3.0

4.0

Currency note

11

2

8

0.020

− 2.331b

21

2.0

4.0

Translucent plastic

6

5

10

0.891

− 0.137b

21

3.0

2.0

  1. aNegative ranks: CNP18 < BP
  2. bPositive ranks: CNP18 > BP
  3. cTies: CNP18 = BP